What are three common objections made toward anyone who tries to answer yali’s question and how does diamond respond to those jared diamond, “yali's question. Guns, germs, and steel study questions essay guns, germs, diamond was investigating our inferred history for clues, to answer yali’s question. I believe the best way to describe yali’s question is to rephrase what the question is asking and what it is trying to answer the question is trying to answer the following: why are the people of the modern world, from a technological, environment, scientific, biological, and historical point of view, in their current environment or worldly .
Guns germs and steel video questions answers yali's question, can be found on page in the book guns germs and steel by jared diamond how does diamond. What is jared diamond’s explanation for yali’s question 2 how have others attempted to answer the yali’s question 3. Diamond realized that he did not have a good answer to yali's question, because he did not know how to explain why some nations had developed more quickly than others. Diamond was determined to seek an answer to yali's question diamond surrounds his answer on how history followed different courses for different people because of .
Start studying history reading questions quiz 1 learn vocabulary, terms, what answers to yali's question have some historians given in the past. The student will develop a 10-12 page term paper that answers yali's question the production of this paper carries the signifi. Need help with prologue: yali’s question in jared diamond's guns, germs, and steel check out our revolutionary side-by-side summary and analysis.
Frequently asked questions q: what does yali stand are not us citizens or applicants who are found to have submitted answers that are not their own . Yali’s question prologue group 1: read pages 13-15 summarize your pages answer: what was yali’s question on page 14, 3 rd paragraph, how did new guinean’s know to value the tools or “cargo” that white europeans brought to australia . Transcript printable version: diamond realized that yali’s question was i had no idea what to say to him then but now i think i know the answer yali it . Diamond tries to answer this question through his patented mixture of environmental as diamond brings this argument back to yali and yali’s question, .
Guns, germs, and steel questions - stephanie ciceri mr as well as diamond, many other people have attempted to answer yali’s question. Yali's question i 5 new guinean and that of the average european or american comparable differences separate the lifestyles of other peoples of the world as well those huge disparities must have potent causes that one might think would be obvious yet yali's apparently simple question is a difficult one to answer i didn't have an answer then. Prologue yali's question the roots of guns, germs, and steel 8 5 the answers to the question don't involve human racial differences at all. Diamond realized that yali's question penetrated the heart of a guns, germs and steel diamond knew that the answer had little to do with .
Jared diamond answers yali's question by saying that the race of a society does not matter the success of a society occurs when a society has good animals for domestication and a good geographic location. When you care about the answer--and you always should--how you ask the question is everything. Jared diamond’s book, guns germs and steel is all about a question that was asked of him by a new guinean politician named yali yali, during the 1970s, asked jared diamond how the whites were more superior in their ways of developing and transporting cargo rather than the blacks who had far less cargo of their own.
Yet yali's apparently simple question is a difficult one to answer i didn't have an answer then . Skinnedmink said kelly, now, while it might seem apparent to us i will ask the question anyway what’s so great about agriculture maybe the answer is nothing. Viewing guide: teacher’s answer key guns, germs, and steel: episode 1 providing as many facts, details, and examples as possible to answer each question. (yali’s question) the author summarizes popular “answers” or “explanations” to yali’s question on pages 18-25 guns, germs, and steel .